The Effectiveness of A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift...

The Effectiveness of A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift A Modest Proposal for preventing the children of poor people in Ireland from being a burden to their parents or country, and for making them beneficial to the public - Jonathan Swift 1729. In reading this you will discover the answer to the above question in three parts;  · How effective is it as an argument  · How effective is it as a piece of information  · How effective is it as satire A Modest Proposal first appeared in public in 1729, Swift wrote this article after all of his previous suggestions had been rejected by the Irish authorities. Swift felt the English government had psychologically exiled him and this greatly added to the rage he felt over†¦show more content†¦English absentee landlords owned most of the land that was valuable so the Irish again could not challenge the might of England. Before Swift introduces his Proposal to the reader he decides to state who the Proposals will benefit and how, It will prevent those voluntary abortions Here is shown that the mother will not have to break the confidence of the Catholic Church in having the banned abortions so the rules of the church are not broken. and that horrid practice of women murdering their bastard children. The so far unmentioned Proposal will already have the appreciation of the reader, as his idea will stop the unlawful killings of unborn and new-born children. Another great advantage is that the children, who will now because of this still be alive, of one year old will contribute to the feeding and partly clothing, of many thousands. Interest into what this Proposal is will be increasing and this is the desired effect as Swift is establishing his ludicrous suggestion but making the audience accept it by creating and increasing this interest. As was once said there are: lies, damn lies and statistics. Although this had not been stated by Swifts time, 1729, this possible manipulative exaggeration of evidence is existent in his Proposal with him using the terms; computed, calculate and computation. These are the statistics with whichShow MoreRelatedA Modest Proposal By Jonathan Swift Essay836 Words   |  4 PagesIn Jonathan Swift’s â€Å"A Modest Proposal†, we are exposed to the timeless issue of homelessness and the state’s role in their social welfare. Swift was a fervent Irish patriot who was disgusted by the flourishing trend of beggars and hungry children that flooded the streets of his beloved country. This topic is relatable as this is a social issue that plagues many countries in the present age. Swift presents a satirical argument in which he proposes Ireland adopt the horrific practices of eating theirRead MoreJonathan Swift s Modest Proposal1562 Words   |  7 PagesEmpire. Thesis: Jonathan Swift s Modest Proposal is the most effective in conveying its proposal against Imperialism as a universal theme. Directional Statement: Jonathan Swift s Modest Proposal successfully uses evidence to support its proposal and an effective style of writing. It also presents a clearly defined problem and solution compared to George Orwell s â€Å"Shooting an Elephant† and Thomas Jefferson s â€Å"Declaration of Independence†. Point 1: Swift s Modest Proposal effectively usesRead MoreJonathan Swift Satire Analysis1108 Words   |  5 Pagesomparing Irony In both Mark Twain and Jonathan Swift’s articles there is an effective use of irony. Irony in satirical writing is normally used for the speaker to convey the opposite intended meaning to which they are stating; along with antiphrasis, the use of a word when the opposite meaning is implied, irony makes a valuable asset to satirical literature. The sarcastic use of irony was input to both readings to express the writer’s disappointment towards their societies teachings during theirRead MoreCompare/Contrast Thomas Jefferson and Jonathan Swift1434 Words   |  6 Pagesthese are questions looking to be answered, with varying degrees of seriousness, by Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Swift. Thomas Jefferson’s A Declaration of Independence may be thought of as a universal symbol of traditional American values, however in it exists several layers of meaning, each appealing to the reader and their sense of social responsibility. While Swift’s A Modest Proposal attemp ts a similar entreaty to the public’s sympathy, it diverges drastically in its use of satire. While the styleRead MoreSatire Modest Proposal Essay837 Words   |  4 Pagesconcerns can fall upon deaf ears and change can be slow or non-existent. However some social commentators, such as Jonathan Swift in his pamphlet A Modest Proposal, use clever, targeted, and ironic criticism to bring the social state of Ireland to the attention of indolent aristocrats. He accomplishes such criticism through satire, specifically Juvenanlian satire. Swift’s A Modest Proposal stands as a perfect example of the type of satire that plays upon the audience’s emotion by creating anger concerningRead MoreJuvenelian Satire in A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift Essay1052 Words   |  5 Pagesblandly protesting grievances or concerns can fall upon deaf ears and change can be slow or non-existent. However, Jonathan Swift in his pamphlet A Modest Proposal, uses clever, targeted, and iro nic criticism to bring the social state of Ireland to the attention of indolent aristocrats. He accomplishes such criticism through satire, specifically Juvenalian satire. Swift’s A Modest Proposal stands as an example of the type of satire that plays upon the audience’s emotion by creating anger concerning theRead MoreEssay on Swifts Powerful Message in A Modest Proposal1136 Words   |  5 PagesSwifts Powerful Message in A Modest Proposal  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚        Ã‚   In the Holy Bible, Jesus Christ states that there will always be poor, pathetic, struggling masses and nothing we can do will ever completely eliminate this element.   Swift also acknowledges the homeless people, but in a different vein than Christ.   In A Modest Proposal, the narrator expresses pity for the poor, but at the same time he strives to maintain his social dominance over them.   According to Swift, the English-Irish commonRead MoreIrony in Jonathan Swifts A Modest Proposal1101 Words   |  5 Pagestype of subject being discussed. The effectiveness of appropriate strategy is directly related to the mood, which is to be created and maintained. For example if someone is criticizing the government, the tome is usually kept serious and Irony and satire are widely used in such writings. On the other hand while describing the recent developments in genetic engineering, the tone would be objective and humor or satire would be ineffective here. Jonathan Swift was famous for his sarcastic remarksRead MoreAnalysis Of On Dumpster Diving Essay1671 Words   |  7 Pagesunwillingness to accept you for who you are can cause some to feel extreme depression Q4: What is the effectiveness in using such unusual ideas or characters in Jonathan Swift’s â€Å"A Modest Proposal.† The effectiveness of using such unusual ideas was to draw the people s attention, rather than allowing them to constantly avoid Ireland s substantial problems he wrote something to make them listen. If Jonathan Swift had written a serious piece simply espousing his true beliefs he would not have received asRead MoreEffective Persuasive Techniques Used By John Donne s `` The Flea ``1480 Words   |  6 Pagesuncover the deeper message. Alternatively, writers may use it in establishing social criticism, while maintaining a humorous undertone. Distinct examples can be shown in John Donne’s poem â€Å"The Flea†, which indicates a logical fallacy, Jonathan Swift’s essay â€Å"A Modest Proposal†, which illustrates a rhetorical device, and JP Sears’ satirical video â€Å"If Meat Eaters Acted Like Vegans†. One of the many components of an effective argumentative technique is a logical fallacy. A logical fallacy is a false or deceptive